, Gloucester, MA

April 26, 2013

Statewide plastic bag bill advancing

By Alan Burke
Staff Writer

---- — MARBLEHEAD — Lori Ehrlich has one word for the Massachusetts Legislature — plastic.

More specifically, the Marblehead state representative — moving forward from where voters in Manchester have already gone — wants a statewide end to your supermarket’s distribution of plastic bags, making an argument that they’ve become an environmental menace, harming beaches, oceans and animal life.

Ehrlich is sponsoring the bill that would make Massachusetts the first state in the nation to outlaw the bags. It’s hit some resistance from legislators who suggest that it might be a case of government overreach and retailers who warn that the policy is likely to cause consumers both inconvenience and money.

Ehrlich’s proposal has nonetheless already picked up steam in the Legislature, winning initial approval from the Environmental, Natural Resources and Agriculture Committee. That was enough to impress Rep. Brad Hill, the Ipswich Republican whose district includes the town of Manchester.

“When the environmental committee put it out as quickly as it did,” Hill said, “it has legs. ... I haven’t seen the bill in its totality. But the underlying intent of the bill is a good one. It’s a very good solution to the pollution of our ocean.”

He praised a feature of the bill that would allow plastic bags if they can be made biodegradable.

It’s the fact that the bags do not break down over time that has caused environmentalists to lament their impact, especially at the seacoast, Ehrlich said.

“Nothing that we use for a few minutes should pollute the ocean for hundreds of years,” said Ehrlich, who launched her political career after working on environmental causes on the North Shore. “Anyone who’s attended a beach cleanup knows how much plastic is in our ocean.”

Those arguments parallel the ones that played out earlier this spring in Manchester, where voters on April 2 emphatically approved a new town bylaw that will ban the distribution of single-use plastic bags by supermarkets, convenience stores, pharmacies and other retailers as of July 1.

In addition to the huge amounts of plastic being swept onto beaches, Ehrlich said, vast floating dumps of discarded plastic are growing at sea. It’s “the great garbage patch. ... In the Pacific, there is a plastic soup the size of two Texases.”

On land, the bags collect everywhere and can be a menace clogging storm drains. Recycling them is too expensive, Ehrlich said.

So, how should people bring their groceries home?

“Paper bags are fine,” Ehrlich said. “They can be recycled. The best thing you can do is bring your own reusable bags.”

The reaction among her fellow legislators has been encouraging, Ehrlich said. “I’m hearing quite a bit of positive feedback.”

On the other hand, Jon Hurst of the Massachusetts Retailers Association opposes the measure. He suggests that the alternatives to plastic have problems of their own. Reusable cloth bags, he noted, have been found to collect bacteria, including deadly salmonella. Paper bags are more expensive, with the cost passed on to consumers.

“Paper bags don’t degrade very fast,” Hurst said. “Paper bags take a whole lot more energy to make; they require a lot more water and a lot more trees to produce.”

Banning plastic, Hurst continued, “isn’t necessarily a pro-consumer thing to do.”

The plastic bags handed out by the supermarket get a lot of secondary use, in trash barrels, for example, to wrap recyclables or even to attend to pet waste.

As to the masses of plastic garbage in the ocean, Hurst questioned how much of that can be traced to plastic bags.

“In our experience dealing with consumers, they like to have options,” he said. “... If you ban them, you’re forcing people to buy bags.”