Mon, Nov 23 2009

Published: January 29, 2008 09:40 am    PrintThis  

Judges' sentiments can't trump the law

By Ray Lamont , Editor
Gloucester Daily Times

Former Gloucester District Court presiding Judge Richard Mori may have had good intentions.

But a reversal last week by the state Supreme Judicial Court of a ruling Mori made two years ago should serve as a caution to all those who sit on the bench - judges are to interpret and enforce the law, not function as social workers.

Judith McCulloch of Mount Pleasant Avenue had pleaded guilty in 2006 to negligent driving and was sentenced to a year of probation in connection with a September 2005 accident on Eastern Avenue.

She was driving a black Lexus owned by Harold Bell, who was in the car with her, when she crossed the center line and collided with a Toyota Camry with four teenagers. Two of them were seriously injured.

But at a restitution hearing in May 2006, Mori accepted a deal proposed by McCulloch's attorney, James McKenna. In exchange for $6,000 to be paid immediately to one of the injured crash victims, Mori erased the guilty finding and the year of probation.

The judge, who has since left the Gloucester court, said the agreement would provide money to the crash victim to pay off student loans for the year of college she missed because of her injuries.

This, the Supreme Judicial Court said, was beyond Mori's authority. While he could reduce the sentence, the conviction could not be erased without an appeal or a new trial.

In short, a compassionate motive does not trump the law.

Judges at all levels should heed the reminder sent by the Supreme Judicial Court.
PrintThis  
More stories from the OLD OPINION section

PLEASE NOTE CHANGES IN POLICY: Commenters are required to have a username with a valid and verified email address. Gloucestertimes.com reserves the right to ban the IP address of any commenter (person) found using multiple aliases under multiple e-mail addresses in a deceptive manner. Posts that do not meet site standards, which can be found here, will be removed.


For a short tutorial on how to sign up to Disqus and verify your email, click here.
Comments powered by Disqus



Resources



PrintThis  
Print Advertisement
Click Image to Enlarge


autoconx
Premier Guide

Daily Email Headlines

Browse our galleries of historic reprints, now available for sale
rtj