, Gloucester, MA


November 19, 2012

Editorial: What does it take for criminal probe of NOAA actions?

So, the new head of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s law enforcement wing is touting his agency as assuring “a level playing field for fishermen.”

And a NOAA promotional video — showing, believe it or not, enforcement agents boarding boats to ensure that “level playing field” — hails them for knowing that “fair and effective enforcement is vital to managing our nation’s fisheries and integral to protecting marine resources and their habitats ...” and even dare to suggest that “the vast majority of fishermen follow the rules and count on us for help.”

Since when did the federal government start producing such blatant works of fiction?

OK, we believe Bruce Buckson, NOAA’s second-year law enforcement director, would like to be able to tout his agency in that fashion. But the reality is, there remains no sign whatsoever that he or NOAA administrator Jane Lubchenco have taken legitimate steps in addressing the heavy-handed tactics used by agents and prosecutors that led to the agency and its parent Commerce Department being cited by its own Inspector General, issuing a Cabinet-level apology to fishermen and doling out more than $600,000 in reparations for excessive enforcement in 2011.

For Buckson and NOAA in general to spend even a dime on this kind of bogus PR when they and the Commerce Department continue to refuse release of the so-called Swartwood II report – a 550-page follow-up report delving deeper into 66 additional cases of excessive NOAA enforcement — is beyond hypocritical. It has reached the point at which it must be considered a criminal obstruction of justice.

By denying the report’s release to U.S. Sen. Scott Brown, Congressman John Tierney and others, Acting Commerce Secretary Rebecca Blank and NOAA’s Lubchenco not only continue show an ongoing lack of accountability to fishermen and taxpayers at large, but a contempt for Congress that has been a Lubchenco hallmark since she took office in 2009 with her job-killing catch share fishery system in tow.

Text Only | Photo Reprints